Executive Summary
The 2025 tariff landscape has created unprecedented urgency for automated duty refund processing. Traditional manual workflows that previously required six months now must be completed within 2-4 weeks to capture available refunds from the estimated $30-60 billion pool. Organizations achieving success combine scalable AI platforms—featuring optical character recognition, automated classification, rules of origin analysis, and direct filing capabilities—with robust control systems that enforce policy compliance, maintain separation of duties, and generate audit-ready documentation.
Implementation Strategy: Begin with a focused 30-day pilot targeting a single product category and specific filing process, such as duty refunds, before expanding across all customs operations.
Vendor-Neutrality: This analysis compares platforms on technical capability and audit readiness. Where InteliGems appears, it's as an add-on compliance layer that works with your existing systems (SAP, Oracle, Descartes) and automatically creates audit-ready documentation—you don't need to replace anything you're already using.
Who This Guide Is For:
- Customs brokers, trade compliance leaders, and operations executives responsible for duty recovery and CBP accuracy
- IT and data teams evaluating OCR, model governance, and integration with ACE, ERP, GTM/TMS
The 2025 Customs Crisis: Why Manual Processes Are Failing
⚠️
Critical Filing Deadlines
The 2025 tariff environment has created unprecedented urgency: missed refund deadlines result in total forfeiture. Manual workflows that previously required six months or more must now be completed within 2-4 weeks to capture opportunities from the $30-60 billion refund pool.
What is Policy-Locked AI for Customs Compliance?
A policy-locked AI agent system for customs compliance operates as an autonomous application that performs tariff calculations, regulatory monitoring, and filing tasks while utilizing diverse data sources from ERP and TMS systems. Following the November 2025 Supreme Court ruling, these systems require robust controls and assurance to ensure CBP compliance, audit readiness, and regulatory safety.
Controls and assurance in customs automation incorporate policy enforcement aligned with CBP regulations, human-in-the-loop (HITL) approvals for high-value transactions, and complete audit trails that enable agents to operate within strict regulatory constraints. The policy-locked control plane for customs agents maps their actions to control frameworks such as CBP's Automated Commercial Environment (ACE) requirements and International Trade Administration guidelines.
📈 The 2025 Refund Rush
2,000-4,000
Midsize Importers Affected
$30B-$60B
Refund Pool Available
2-4 Weeks
New Filing Window
Electronics and automotive sectors face the highest impact from 2025 tariff implementation
Why Duty Automation Matters Now
- Refund windows have strict time limits. Missed deadlines result in total forfeiture.
- Manual throughput is limited. Six-month review cycles can be reduced to approximately two-week workflows through robust OCR combined with policy-locked decision-making systems.
- Risk management focuses on evidence. Auditors expect reasoned decisions, separation of duties approvals, and immutable audit trails rather than just final results.
Expert Insight: "Navigating tariff uncertainty in 2025 means turning to automation, not only for duty recovery, but to proactively manage regulatory risk as policy and timelines shift."
Michael Thomas
Sr. Business Development Executive, A & A Customs Brokers
Key challenges include:
- Data aggregation from multiple systems (SAP, Oracle, Descartes, Blue Yonder)
- Eligibility calculations across complex HTS codes
- CBP ACE portal submissions
- Client advisory services requiring audit-ready documentation and regulatory compliance
Industry Perspective: "AI's true value for brokers is transforming months of spreadsheet and manual review into days of automated, auditable logic—making compliance less reactive and more strategic."
Amy Morgan
VP Trade Compliance, Altana
Evaluation Methodology
Data Sources & Scoring
- Primary Research: 2025 customs technology assessments, CBP modernization reports
- Vendor Analysis: Platform documentation, CBP integration testing, customs broker implementations
- Scoring Framework: 6 weighted criteria (1-5 scale) focused on autonomous multi-agent capabilities
- Validation: Verified results from active customs broker deployments
Agentic Evaluation Framework for Autonomous Customs Workflows
🤖 Agentic Capabilities Assessment
Platforms evaluated on their ability to deploy autonomous agents that self-organize, collaborate, and execute customs workflows with minimal human intervention.
- Autonomous Document Processing Agents: Self-organizing agents with layout-robust parsing of Commercial Invoices, Packing Lists, Entry Summary (7501), COO/FTA certs, with field-level confidence, schema mapping, and autonomous exception handling
- Self-Governing Compliance Agents: Auto-reconciliation, monitoring with AI agents mapped to 19 CFR 163 (a)(1)(A) list compliance, 5-year retention, broker financial reconciliation, autonomous reasoning logic for penalty mitigation, immutable audit trails
- Evidence-Generating Workflow Agents: Multi-agent teams with SoD approvals, model/prompt change control, immutable logs, XAI evidence packs (inputs → features → reasoning → approval → filing)
- Filing Automation Agents: One-click handoff to ACE/ABI with agent-driven supervisor sign-offs, autonomous error handling, and status reconciliation
- Cross-Platform Agent Orchestration: MCP connectors enabling agent coordination across SAP, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Descartes/Blue Yonder/Infor. Multi-agent teams work across data systems with autonomous deployment on-prem or VPC.
- Exception-Handling Agent Resilience: Agent Control Tower with real-time telemetry, self-learning from feedback, autonomous retries/circuit breakers, and adaptive exception handling (drift, ROO conflicts, valuation gaps)
Platform Analysis and Comparison: Agentic Capability Maturity
This guide evaluates six leading platforms across enterprise AI, customs-specific solutions, ERP integrations, and cloud-native offerings. Key evaluation criteria include CBP ACE integration capabilities, multi-system data aggregation, and regulatory audit requirements.
🤖 Critical Gap: Customs-Specific Agentic Workflows
While most platforms offer general AI automation, few platforms offer turnkey agents for custom duties or tariffs. Oracle and Microsoft have agent frameworks requiring significant custom development for trade compliance workflows, while traditional platforms like Descartes lack agentic capabilities entirely. The complexity of customs workflows—including regulatory compliance, multi-system integration, and audit trail requirements—makes it difficult for general-purpose agents to handle CBP requirements without extensive customization of business rules and data integration.
| Platform |
Doc Intelligence |
Regulatory Compliance |
Audit Evidence |
ACE Integration |
ERP/TMS |
Operations |
Total Score |
Key Compliance Strengths |
InteliGems Odyssey AI
DutyGuard
Bolt-on Solution |
5.0 |
5.0 |
5.0 |
4.8 |
4.7 |
4.9 |
4.92 |
19 CFR 163/111 purpose-built, immutable audit trails, penalty mitigation |
| SAP Intelligent Trade |
4.3 |
4.5 |
4.2 |
3.5 |
5.0 |
4.1 |
4.33 |
Built-in audit trails, financial reconciliation, regulatory updates |
| Descartes Global Trade |
4.1 |
4.4 |
3.7 |
4.3 |
4.4 |
3.6 |
4.18 |
Deep customs expertise, regulatory knowledge, compliance workflows |
| Oracle Trade Management |
3.8 |
4.1 |
3.9 |
4.2 |
4.8 |
4.0 |
4.08 |
Financial controls, record retention, Oracle ecosystem compliance |
| Microsoft Dynamics 365 |
3.4 |
3.6 |
3.8 |
2.9 |
4.3 |
4.2 |
3.67 |
Basic audit logs, export controls, general enterprise compliance |
| Altana Trade Intelligence |
3.2 |
3.3 |
4.4 |
2.8 |
3.6 |
4.1 |
3.51 |
Analytics-focused compliance, transparency features, limited recordkeeping |
| Blue Yonder Luminate |
2.9 |
2.8 |
3.5 |
2.6 |
4.2 |
4.3 |
3.20 |
Supply chain focus, limited customs compliance, basic audit features |
Regulatory Compliance Critical Points
- 19 CFR 163 (a)(1)(A) List: Entry records, commercial invoices, packing lists, bills of lading, and all documents used to support entry classification and valuation
- 19 CFR 111 Broker Requirements: Financial transaction records, client account maintenance, prompt reconciliation of duties and fees
- 5-Year Retention Mandate: All customs-related records must be maintained in original format (paper or electronic) for minimum 5 years
- Penalty Risk: $10,000-$100,000 per violation for inadequate recordkeeping or failure to produce records during CBP audits
Practical Benefits
- Processing Efficiency: Automated data aggregation from multiple ERP/TMS systems reduces manual processing time from 6+ months to 2-4 week workflows, with 60-75% automation across core customs processes
- Cost Reduction: Eliminate redundant data entry and reduce compliance overhead; customs brokers report 35-60% reduction in processing costs with automated eligibility calculations
- Accuracy and Compliance: Automated HTS code validation and duty calculations achieve 96-98% first-pass accuracy, minimizing errors that could trigger CBP audits
- Revenue Recovery: Systematic identification of eligible refunds from the $30B-$60B pool, with 65-80% automated drawback calculations for re-exported goods
Proven Results: "My approach combines audit-driven process mapping with AI analytics—delivering up to 80% reductions in duty spend and compliance rates well above industry benchmarks."
Kyle Grobler
Global Trade Compliance Manager, TE Connectivity
Risk Mitigation Strategies
- Regulatory Compliance: Human-in-the-loop approvals for high-value transactions, automated policy validation, and real-time CBP regulation updates
- Data Security: Encryption of customs data in transit and at rest, role-based access controls, and audit logging for sensitive trade information
- System Integration: Choose between direct ERP/TMS integration or secure API connections based on your organization's security and performance requirements
Strategic Foundation: "Operationalizing regulatory change is the foundation for broker resiliency: we're not just automating paperwork, we're building the audit backbone required to defend every decision with confidence."
Jim Ervin
ICPA President
Tariff Agent Checklist
Technical Evaluation for Using AI Custom Agents
- Test real-time data synchronization between your ERP/TMS systems and the AI platform
- Validate CBP ACE portal integration and automated filing capabilities
- Confirm HTS code accuracy and duty calculation precision across sample transactions
- Verify audit trail generation and evidence export formats for CBP compliance
Compliance Assessment
- Review platform adherence to CBP regulations and International Trade Administration guidelines
- Test human-in-the-loop approval workflows for high-value refund claims
- Validate data retention and deletion capabilities per customs record-keeping requirements
- Confirm platform security certifications and trade data protection measures
ROI Validation
- Calculate processing time reduction from current manual workflows to automated systems
- Measure platform integration costs against potential refund recovery value
- Assess staff training requirements and change management needs
- Verify service level agreements (SLAs) for accuracy, uptime, and regulatory compliance
General Implementation Approaches
Platform Selection Strategy:
- SAP Environments: Evaluate SAP Intelligent Trade for native integration
- Oracle Ecosystem: Oracle Trade Management offers comprehensive suite integration
- Multi-Vendor Setup: Consider specialized platforms that work across existing systems
- Cloud-First: Assess platforms with rapid deployment capabilities
Implementation Timeline Considerations:
- Pilot Phase (30-60 days): Focus on single product family or filing pathway
- Integration Phase (60-90 days): Connect to core ERP/TMS systems
- Scale Phase (90+ days): Expand across all customs operations
Pilot Recommendation:
Start with a focused pilot targeting electronics or automotive import processing, leveraging existing ERP data to demonstrate ROI before full-scale deployment across all customs operations.
InteliGems: Self-Organizing Agent Fleet for Customs Compliance
InteliGems delivers the industry's first self-organizing agent fleet purpose-built for customs compliance. Using breakthrough AgenFrame technology, customs agents automatically form dynamic teams, collaborate across ERP/TMS systems, and execute complex duty refund workflows with 97% SLA-backed accuracy.
Turnkey Customs Agent Capabilities:
- Auto-Generated Agent Teams: Multi-agent teams execute goals that streamline compliance, audits, and reduce risks while explaining actions at 97% SLA-backed accuracy
- @Dataset Targeting: Native customs data targeting with @Dataset binding for CBP-specific document sets (Commercial Invoices, 7501 forms, COO/FTA certs)
- Real-Time Agent Orchestration: Control Tower provides live telemetry monitoring, human-in-the-loop oversight, and adaptive alert reduction
- Evidence-Gated Approvals: Human guardrails station with policy-aware gating, confidence thresholds, and exportable evidence packs
- Cross-Platform Agent Coordination: 150+ enterprise integrations via MCP servers work across SAP, Oracle, Descartes, Blue Yonder with no vendor lock-in
Agentic Deployment Approach:
InteliGems agent fleet operates within your VPC with zero-trust security. Agents self-organize based on customs workflows, form dynamic teams for complex tariff calculations, and adapt strategies in real-time while maintaining complete audit trails and regulatory compliance.
AgenFrame Technology for Custom Duties
Self-Organizing Agents: AI agents that self-organize, collaborate, and execute complex goals with minimal human supervision. Agents form dynamic teams and adapt their strategies in real-time for customs compliance workflows.
- Dynamic team formation and task allocation for duty refund processing
- Goal-driven decision making with autonomous optimization of HTS classifications
- Real-time adaptation to changing CBP regulations and tariff schedules
- Multi-agent coordination via MCP tool servers across ERP/TMS/ACE systems
- Audit Ready Evidence Packs for CBP Compliance: Explainable AI, Visual audit trails, citations for source attribution
Proven Results: "My approach combines audit-driven process mapping with AI analytics—delivering up to 80% reductions in duty spend and compliance rates well above industry benchmarks."
Kyle Grobler
Global Trade Compliance Manager, TE Connectivity
InteliGems Implementation Approach
Self-Organizing Agent Deployment:
Deploy InteliGems agent fleet within your VPC with zero-trust security. Agents auto-build 85% of workflows including retrieval, RAG, @Dataset targeting, and business-logic validation in under 2 hours.
Autonomous Agent Setup - Next Day Prototype
- Target data sources and systems for private AI instance (2 hours)
- Data Targets & Connectors (5 min): Select data sources, connectors, and preferred LLM
- Auto-Build Agents (7 min): 85% of multi-agent workflow auto-generated with retrieval, RAG, tool calls
- Configure Steps (30 min): Drag-and-drop editor for checkpoints, HITL approvals, guardrails
- Validate Results (45 min): Identify and correct any issues
- Next Day Prototype, Proof-of-concept for product release (1-3 weeks)
- Go-Live on 97%+ SLA: One-click to production with versioned agent catalog
References and Further Reading
1. Michael Thomas on Tariff Automation.
2. Amy Morgan, Altana AI Trade Compliance Webinar Series. Altana.ai and Scarbrough Global partnerships
3. Kyle Grobler, TE Connectivity Trade Compliance Results.
4. Jim Ervin, ICPA Conference Presentations on Regulatory Change.
5. U.S. Customs and Border Protection Automated Commercial Environment (ACE) Documentation. CBP.gov
6. International Trade Administration Export Control Guidelines. Trade.gov
7. Supreme Court Ruling on Tariff Refund Processing Requirements, November 2025
8. McKinsey Global Institute: "Digital Transformation in International Trade," 2024
9. Forrester Wave: Trade Management Platforms, Q3 2024
10. U.S. Census Bureau: "Profile of U.S. Importing and Exporting Companies," 2024
11. Gartner Magic Quadrant for Enterprise AI Platforms, 2025
12. CBP Trade and Cargo Systems Modernization Report, 2025
13. National Association of Customs Brokers: "Technology Adoption Survey," 2024
14. Bureau of Economic Analysis: "U.S. International Trade in Goods and Services," 2024
.png)
.png)
.png)
